Mortgage protection leads: prices by format, and the cost per sale once you call them
Every page that ranks for this is written by someone selling the leads. They publish the price of a card and, at best, a close rate they say is not measured. None of them says what it costs to call the cards. This page adds that line.

The same sum for other lines is on final expense leads cost, health insurance leads cost and auto insurance leads cost. The dialers life agents compare are on the best dialer for life insurance agents, and the category as a whole on the best power dialer software and the cheapest power dialers.
Mortgage protection leads for sale: every format, priced
| Format | Price | Billed | Seller |
|---|---|---|---|
| Aged lead, 365+ days | $0.75 | Per record | InsureLeads |
| Aged lead, 30–90 days | $5 | Per record | InsureLeads |
| Direct mail you run (CPM) | $375–700 | Per 1,000 pieces | Redbird Agents |
| First-class mail, new mortgage data | $550–700 | Per 1,000 pieces | Redbird Agents |
| Fixed-cost direct mail card | $35–60 | Per card returned | Redbird Agents |
| Exclusive real-time web lead | $55 | Per lead | InsureLeads |
| Contact-verified lead | $80 | Per lead | InsureLeads |
| Interest-verified live transfer | $150 | Per connected call | InsureLeads |
| Preset appointment | $225 / $300 | Confirmed / kept | InsureLeads |
InsureLeads: getinsureleads.com/mortgage-protection-insurance-leads (page dated April 13, 2026), read November 21, 2026; state, filters and volume move its final quote. Redbird Agents: redbirdagents.com/insurance-leads/mortgage-protection-leads, read November 21, 2026; it brokers several vendors and quotes ranges. We do not sell leads and have no arrangement with either.
Two things the rate cards leave out. Aged records are not exclusive: InsureLeads says so plainly, and a card that was resold has been called by someone before you. And every format but the transfer and the appointment arrives as a name and a number you still have to reach.
Mortgage protection mailer leads: run the mail, or buy the cards
Running the mail yourself is cheaper per card in a good week and more expensive in a bad one, which is the whole case for fixed-cost cards: the vendor keeps mailing until you have the cards you paid for. A card is a homeowner asking to be contacted, so it is the lead you call first, within the day it arrives. Most mortgage protection agents call the card, then knock the door if the phone does not reach anyone.
Aged mortgage protection leads: the cheapest records, the most dials
| Aged mortgage protection leads | Cost |
|---|---|
| 1,000 leads at $0.75 (365+ days) | $750 |
| Dialing each 3 times: 3,000 dials, ~143 a working day | $91 |
| Month, leads and dialing | $841 |
| Dialing per lead | $0.09 |
One DialSheet agent on the parallel dialer: $29 seat, their own Twilio from perRepTelephony() with both call legs and a number, answering machine detection at $0.0075 a dial, 21 working days. The call mix is an example, not an industry figure: 25% voicemail, 10% a person for three minutes.
On a year-old file the question is how many dials it takes to reach a person, which is where a parallel dialer earns its seat: it rings two to 5 numbers at once and connects the first one that answers. On a fresh card or web lead the question is speed: one line, within minutes, before the next agent who bought the same name.

Cost per sale, worked from your own close count
| Policies placed in the month (your input) | Web leads: $2,235 | Mail: $735 | Aged: $841 |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | $2,235 | $735 | $841 |
| 2 | $1,118 | $368 | $421 |
| 4 | $559 | $184 | $210 |
| 6 | $373 | $123 | $140 |
| 8 | $279 | $92 | $105 |
Web leads: 40 InsureLeads exclusive web leads at $55 plus a month on one line ($35). Mail: 1,000 first-class pieces at $700 plus the same month of calling. Aged: 1,000 leads at $0.75 dialed three times on the parallel dialer. The policy counts are examples for you to replace, not a forecast or a measured rate; your time, mileage for appointments and chargebacks are left out.
- The formula. (leads + dialing + minutes + anything else the month used) ÷ policies placed. InsureLeads runs the same sum at its own 15% planning figure and gets about $367 of web leads per closed sale; it says its 12–20% band is a published planning range, not measured client results.
- Count placed, not submitted. A policy that lapses or charges back comes off the count in the month it comes back.
- Compare per conversation. A $150 transfer is one conversation. $841 of aged leads dialed three times is however many conversations your list gives you; count them for a week before you decide.
A mortgage protection dialer: load the cards and call them today
- Export. Download the lead file from the seller or your IMO’s portal as a CSV: name, phone, address, mortgage amount and lender, the date the card came in.
- Import. Upload it and map the columns; the walkthrough is how to call a list of leads from a spreadsheet. Mortgage amount and lender can go into custom fields so they sit beside the call.
- Get a line. Connect your own Twilio account, or buy a DialSheet-managed line with a local number.
- Dial. Power Dial on one line for fresh cards and web leads, or a parallel session on two to 5 lines for an aged file. Calling a number twice in a row is covered on double dialing.

What we do not have

Who runs on it
An insurance agency runs 1,000 calls a month, retained month over month. Also: a solo funding desk, and a customer's own story on its own site.
- dialsheet.ioindependent insurance agencyAn insurance agency runs 1,000 calls a month, retained month over month
- dialsheet.iosolo business-funding deskA solo funding broker dials every single week — 1,335 calls last month
- goodroofing.caHow we book estimatesA Calgary roofer on how a storm-season team calls every homeowner in order, with local numbers and no missed follow-ups. “Our calling runs on DialSheet.”
Mortgage protection lead questions
How much do mortgage protection leads cost?
It depends on the format. InsureLeads' published mortgage protection row (read November 21, 2026): $55 for an exclusive real-time web lead, $80 contact-verified, $150 for a live transfer, $225 for a confirmed appointment and $0.75 to $5 for an aged lead by age. Redbird Agents quotes $35 to $60 for a fixed-cost direct mail card and $375 to $700 per 1,000 pieces if you run the mail yourself. Calling them is a separate cost: on DialSheet's parallel dialer, about $91 a month to dial 1,000 aged leads three times each, seat and minutes included.
How much are aged mortgage protection leads?
InsureLeads lists aged mortgage protection leads at $5 for records 30 to 90 days old down to $0.75 for 365 days and older, and says aged records are not exclusive unless they were never resold. Redbird Agents calls aged B and C leads "a few bucks per lead". So 1,000 year-old leads are about $750. They are the cheapest records and the hardest to reach, so the calling matters more: three dials each on DialSheet's parallel dialer is about $91 for the month.
What do mortgage protection mailer leads cost?
Two ways to buy them. Run the mail yourself: Redbird Agents quotes $375 to $700 per 1,000 pieces, $550 to $700 for first class with new mortgage data, and says to expect about 1% back, so 1,000 first-class pieces at $700 return about 10 cards, roughly $70 a card. Or buy fixed-cost cards, where the mail house carries the response risk: $35 to $60 a card at Redbird. Either way you then call or knock the cards.
What does a mortgage protection sale cost in leads?
Divide everything the month cost by the policies it placed: (leads + dialing + minutes) ÷ policies. 40 exclusive web leads at $55 plus a month of calling on DialSheet ($35) is $2,235: $559 a sale at 4 sales and $373 at 6. Those sale counts are examples; use your own. InsureLeads runs the same sum at its own 15% planning figure and gets about $367 of web leads per closed sale, before any calling cost.
Mortgage protection leads on Reddit: what should I ask a vendor?
Ask four things before you buy: whether the lead is exclusive or shared, how old it is and whether it has been resold, what consent record comes with it, and what happens to a wrong number. InsureLeads answers two of them on its own page: fresh leads go to one agent, aged ones are not exclusive unless never resold, and bad numbers on fresh leads are replaced if flagged within 72 hours. Then judge the vendor by what a placed policy cost you, not by the price of a lead.
Do I need a dialer for mortgage protection leads?
For a handful of fresh cards a week, no: call each within minutes from any phone. For aged leads, yes: reaching people on a year-old file takes several dials each, and DialSheet's parallel dialer rings two to 5 numbers at once for $29 a seat, month to month, on your own Twilio at ~$0.014/min. The free plan covers 500 calls a month to try it. If you only buy live transfers, you need a phone that answers, not a dialer.
Lead prices are each seller’s published figures: InsureLeads (getinsureleads.com/mortgage-protection-insurance-leads) and Redbird Agents (redbirdagents.com/insurance-leads/mortgage-protection-leads), both read November 21, 2026. We build DialSheet, so weigh the dialing figures accordingly.